CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing

CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing

Description:

This document represents the formal specification for an unofficial formal extension of the CIDOC CRM designed for application in the area of art and architectural historical research. The scope of this extension is to support art and architectural research in the sense of the study of primary and secondary documents for the derivation, manually and programmatically, of historically contextual facts that can be used to support reflection and structured argumentation. The core expressivity that this extension adds is the ability to accurately express historically bound, contextual social facts relative to the agents holding those beliefs and the temporal period for which those beliefs were valid. The extension enables this expressivity by introducing the notions of institutional fact and speech act as core modelling concepts. Institutional facts are collective beliefs about the world held by groups for a period of time. Such collective beliefs while subjectively grounded are epistemically objective for the community over which they hold sway. Introducing the notion of institutional fact allows for a specialization of the core CRM to be able to express these social realities (expressed in simple, aoristic binary properties in the core CRM) in their full social complexity as temporally and socially bound beliefs. The concomitant core notion introduced in this extension is the idea of Speech Act in the Austinian and Serlean sense. A speech act is a kind of intentional event (E7 Activity of CRM base) in which agents purposefully apply a rule and perform a set practice in order to bring about a new social state or institutional fact. Introducing the notion of speech act provides both a high level ontological category and set of relations for describing the kinds of events which are the cause of institutional facts as well as providing a starting point for the analysis of the non truth propositional use of information objects. In speech acts, information objects (e.g. phrases and formulae) are deployed not to convey states of the world but to generate states of the world. The subject of historical investigation is not simply the bare facts available to an empirical analysis of the physical world but involves an investigation of the social activities which generated contexts of understanding and belief that may differ significantly across times and peoples. Materializing the social facts implicit in CRM base as explicit institutional facts gives them a richer ontological representation and offers a consistent epistemological approach to their study by recognizing social, negotiated facts as objective realities in themselves and treating them as first order entities of study. This involves a departure from the aims of CRM base which is guided by an information integration functionality which favours the representation of the latest state of knowledge in a presentist perspective. In the study of the history of art and architecture it is in no small part the different non-coinciding facts held or supported by different actors over different times which are of interest. The materialization of institutional facts supports the information management functionality which guides this informal extension of the CIDOC CRM and which aims to support historians in representing the positive knowledge they can gather from primary and secondary sources of evidence of both past simple and institutional facts for the purposes of proposing hypotheses and analyses of texts, authors, periods, works and so on. In this regard, CRMaaa also provides an initial limited set of classes for describing traditional and digital methods of deriving facts from texts, in order to support the linking of contemporary research processes as provenance nodes for the different data points of simple and institutional facts which they generate in the course of their research.

Examples Used

With this in mind, examples have been chosen which potentially support a variety of social facts. Some of these facts, i.e., those held by one group of people at some time or other, may directly contradict another, i.e., that held by a different group of people at some potentially different time. Most of the examples have been reused across different types of social fact, in order to tell more completely the history of the objects in question and the beliefs that have been held about them by specific groups of people over a given period of time. These histories can in themselves be quite complex. References are thus provided for further contextualization. These appear in brackets following the examples, like so:

  • The Ownership Status (ZE8) of the Gʼpsgolox totem pole (E22) as 'has current owner' the Haisla people (E74) from 1872 - 2012 holds for the Haisla people (E74) and as 'has current owner' the Swedish National Museum of Ethnography (E74) from 1929 - 2006 holds for the Swedish Polity. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%CA%BCpsgolox_totem_pole)

Compatibility and Nomenclature

This unofficial extension of the CIDOC CRM is formulated in relation to:

  • CIDOC CRM v.7.1.2
  • CIDOC CRM Dig v.4.0

The specification consists of a set of declarations for formalized classes and properties that extend the CIDOC CRM and the above official extensions. 

Adopting the conventions of the CIDOC CRM each class and property have been given an identifier in addition to their names. The naming convention adopted for this extension is:

ZE = class

ZP = property

The choice of these names was arbitrary, making a conceptual connection with the official CRM representation while clearly distinguishing the new classes and properties from those of either CRM base or its official extensions.

Namespace

https://takin.solutions/ontologies/crmaaa 

 

Maintenance and Archiving

CRMaaa is an actively maintained ontology. It is our aim to develop publicaly and participatively, learning from and engaging with the scholarly community that adopts it. Towards this end we maintain the ontology with the following processes and relative tools.

Ontology Development

We adopt the OntoMe tool developed by LARHRA to manage the ontology and produce editions. This ensures a consistent management of the ontology and provides a public space to engage in revisions.

The maintenace space for the ontology can be found here: https://ontome.net/project/69 

Please note, at time of publishing, OntoME is not capable of producing complete, provenanced RDF serializations, so please only use the official RDF for this standard stored on our github. See below. 

Issue Management and Revision Storage

We adopt github as a platform for inviting and managing issues related to the ontology as well as providing an active place to be able to access the latest edition of the ontology, its specification and relevant documentation.

The address for the github repository is: https://github.com/takinsolutions/crmaaa 

Acknowledgements

The initiative for creating, developing and maintaining this ontology is made possible by important on-going funding and institutional commitment, which is gratefully acknowledged here.

Funding Support

Institutional Support

The continuous maintenance and promotion of CRMaaa is made possible by the initial commitment of its partners to maintain the ontology and promote its understanding and adoption.

 

Status:

Ongoing

Contributors:

George Bruseker, Matthew Fielding, Denitsa Nenova

Description

Show Description Language Namespace
This document represents the formal specification for an unofficial formal extension of the CIDOC CRM designed for application in the area of art and architectural historical research. The scope of this extension is to support art and architectural research in the sense of the study of primary and secondary documents for the derivation, manually and programmatically, of historically contextual facts that can be used to support reflection and structured argumentation. The core expressivity that this extension adds is the ability to accurately express historically bound, contextual social facts relative to the agents holding those beliefs and the temporal period for which those beliefs were valid. The extension enables this expressivity by introducing the notions of institutional fact and speech act as core modelling concepts. Institutional facts are collective beliefs about the world held by groups for a period of time. Such collective beliefs while subjectively grounded are epistemically objective for the community over which they hold sway. Introducing the notion of institutional fact allows for a specialization of the core CRM to be able to express these social realities (expressed in simple, aoristic binary properties in the core CRM) in their full social complexity as temporally and socially bound beliefs. The concomitant core notion introduced in this extension is the idea of Speech Act in the Austinian and Serlean sense. A speech act is a kind of intentional event (E7 Activity of CRM base) in which agents purposefully apply a rule and perform a set practice in order to bring about a new social state or institutional fact. Introducing the notion of speech act provides both a high level ontological category and set of relations for describing the kinds of events which are the cause of institutional facts as well as providing a starting point for the analysis of the non truth propositional use of information objects. In speech acts, information objects (e.g. phrases and formulae) are deployed not to convey states of the world but to generate states of the world. The subject of historical investigation is not simply the bare facts available to an empirical analysis of the physical world but involves an investigation of the social activities which generated contexts of understanding and belief that may differ significantly across times and peoples. Materializing the social facts implicit in CRM base as explicit institutional facts gives them a richer ontological representation and offers a consistent epistemological approach to their study by recognizing social, negotiated facts as objective realities in themselves and treating them as first order entities of study. This involves a departure from the aims of CRM base which is guided by an information integration functionality which favours the representation of the latest state of knowledge in a presentist perspective. In the study of the history of art and architecture it is in no small part the different non-coinciding facts held or supported by different actors over different times which are of interest. The materialization of institutional facts supports the information management functionality which guides this informal extension of the CIDOC CRM and which aims to support historians in representing the positive knowledge they can gather from primary and secondary sources of evidence of both past simple and institutional facts for the purposes of proposing hypotheses and analyses of texts, authors, periods, works and so on. In this regard, CRMaaa also provides an initial limited set of classes for describing traditional and digital methods of deriving facts from texts, in order to support the linking of contemporary research processes as provenance nodes for the different data points of simple and institutional facts which they generate in the course of their research. Examples Used With this in mind, examples have been chosen which potentially support a variety of social facts. Some of these facts, i.e., those held by one group of people at some time or other, may directly contradict another, i.e., that held by a different group of people at some potentially different time. Most of the examples have been reused across different types of social fact, in order to tell more completely the history of the objects in question and the beliefs that have been held about them by specific groups of people over a given period of time. These histories can in themselves be quite complex. References are thus provided for further contextualization. These appear in brackets following the examples, like so: The Ownership Status (ZE8) of the Gʼpsgolox totem pole (E22) as 'has current owner' the Haisla people (E74) from 1872 - 2012 holds for the Haisla people (E74) and as 'has current owner' the Swedish National Museum of Ethnography (E74) from 1929 - 2006 holds for the Swedish Polity. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%CA%BCpsgolox_totem_pole) Compatibility and Nomenclature This unofficial extension of the CIDOC CRM is formulated in relation to: CIDOC CRM v.7.1.2 CIDOC CRM Dig v.4.0 The specification consists of a set of declarations for formalized classes and properties that extend the CIDOC CRM and the above official extensions.  Adopting the conventions of the CIDOC CRM each class and property have been given an identifier in addition to their names. The naming convention adopted for this extension is: ZE = class ZP = property The choice of these names was arbitrary, making a conceptual connection with the official CRM representation while clearly distinguishing the new classes and properties from those of either CRM base or its official extensions. Namespace https://takin.solutions/ontologies/crmaaa    Maintenance and Archiving CRMaaa is an actively maintained ontology. It is our aim to develop publicaly and participatively, learning from and engaging with the scholarly community that adopts it. Towards this end we maintain the ontology with the following processes and relative tools. Ontology Development We adopt the OntoMe tool developed by LARHRA to manage the ontology and produce editions. This ensures a consistent management of the ontology and provides a public space to engage in revisions. The maintenace space for the ontology can be found here: https://ontome.net/project/69  Please note, at time of publishing, OntoME is not capable of producing complete, provenanced RDF serializations, so please only use the official RDF for this standard stored on our github. See below.  Issue Management and Revision Storage We adopt github as a platform for inviting and managing issues related to the ontology as well as providing an active place to be able to access the latest edition of the ontology, its specification and relevant documentation. The address for the github repository is: https://github.com/takinsolutions/crmaaa  Acknowledgements The initiative for creating, developing and maintaining this ontology is made possible by important on-going funding and institutional commitment, which is gratefully acknowledged here. Funding Support The development of the initial version (v0.9) of CRMaaa was initiated and generously funded by ETH Zurich, Chair of the History and Theory of Architecture, Prof. Maarten Delbeke. The  continuted development and enrichment of the latest version (v1.5) has been generously funded as part of the Open Research Data (ORD) initiative by swissuniversities. Institutional Support The continuous maintenance and promotion of CRMaaa is made possible by the initial commitment of its partners to maintain the ontology and promote its understanding and adoption. Swiss Art Research Infrastructure - University of Zurich Takin.solutions   en WIP

Contributors

George Bruseker, Matthew Fielding, Denitsa Nenova

Identification

Base URI: https://takin.solutions/ontologies/crmaaa/

Project of belonging: CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation

This namespace is ongoing and can be modified at any time. It is not advisable to use its classes and properties.

Namespaces to which this ongoing namespace refers

Namespace
CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2
CRMdig version 4.0
Referenced:

Labels

Label Language Last updated
CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing * en 2023-11-27

* : Standard label for this language

Versions

CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing is an ongoing namespace.

Root namespace: CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation

Published versions

Namespace Publication date
CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5 2023-10-31

Classes

Identifier Class Last updated Validation status
ZE34 Declarative Dissolution 2023-10-31 Validated
ZE33 Declarative Formation 2023-10-31 Validated
ZE32 Institutional Status 2023-10-31 Denied (see comment)
ZE31 Group Role Assignment 2023-10-31 Denied (see comment)
ZE28 Obligation Status 2023-10-31 Validated
ZE27 Declaration of Obligation 2023-10-31 Validated
ZE26 Dating Declaration 2023-10-31 Validated
ZE25 Dating Status 2023-10-31 Validated
ZE23 Declarative Leaving 2023-10-31 Validated
ZE22 Declarative Joining 2023-10-31 Validated
ZE21 Declarative Transfer of Custody 2023-10-31 Validated
ZE20 Declarative Acquisition 2023-10-31 Validated
ZE30 Property Right Status 2023-10-31 Validated
ZE29 Transfer of Property Right 2023-10-31 Validated
ZE19 Naming 2023-10-31 Validated
ZE18 Critical Reading 2023-10-31 Validated
ZE17 Digital Reading 2023-11-10 Validated
ZE16 Utterance Event 2023-10-31 Denied (see comment)
ZE24 Notional Set 2023-10-31 Validated
ZE15 Set Status 2023-10-31 Validated
ZE14 Similarity Status 2023-10-31 Validated
ZE99 test class 2023-11-28 Denied (see comment)
ZE13 Speech Act 2023-11-28 Validated
ZE12 Referential Status 2023-11-28 Validated
ZE11 Membership Status 2023-11-28 Validated
ZE10 Family Status 2023-11-28 Validated
ZE9 Residential Status 2023-11-28 Validated
ZE8 Ownership Status 2023-11-28 Validated
ZE7 Custodial Status 2023-11-28 Validated
ZE6 Social Status 2023-11-28 Validated
ZE5 Function Status 2023-11-28 Validated
ZE4 Classificatory Status 2023-11-28 Validated
ZE3 Contact Point Status 2023-11-28 Validated
ZE2 Appellative Status 2023-11-28 Validated
ZE1 Institutional Fact 2023-11-28 Validated

Properties

Domain Domain namespace Identifier Property Range Range namespace Last updated Validation status
Institutional Fact – ZE1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP76 applies for context type (is context type for) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Contact Point Status – ZE3 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP9 ascribes contact point (is contact point ascribed by) Identifier – E42 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Institutional Fact – ZE1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP75 applies for context (is context for) Event – E5 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Ownership Status – ZE8 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP23 has ownership subject (is ownership subject of) Physical Thing – E18 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Speech Act – ZE13 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP74 terminated institutional fact for (had institutional fact terminated by) Group – E74 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Custodial Status – ZE7 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP20 has custodial subject (is custodial subject of) Physical Thing – E18 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Function Status – ZE5 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP14 has functional subject (is functional subject of) CRM Entity – E1 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Declaration of Obligation – ZE27 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP69 generated obligation of (had obligation generated of by) Dimension – E54 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Declaration of Obligation – ZE27 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP68 generated obligation to (had obligation to generated by) Actor – E39 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Declaration of Obligation – ZE27 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP67 generated obligation upon (had obligation generated upon by) Actor – E39 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Social Status – ZE6 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP70 ascribes social status in relation to (is related to held social status) Actor – E39 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-11-03 Validated
Institutional Status – ZE32 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP73 ascribes institutional status relation (is institutional status relation ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 Denied (see comment)
Institutional Status – ZE32 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP72 ascribes institutional status (is institutional status ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 Denied (see comment)
Institutional Status – ZE32 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP71 has institutional status subject (is institutional status subject of) Group – E74 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 Denied (see comment)
Speech Act – ZE13 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP53 initiated institutional fact for (had institutional fact initiated by) Group – E74 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Speech Act – ZE13 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP52 intentionally terminated (was intentionally terminated by) Institutional Fact – ZE1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-10-31 Validated
Obligation Status – ZE28 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP58 ascribes debtor (is debtor ascribed by) Actor – E39 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Property Right Status – ZE30 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP66 ascribes property right relation (is property right relation ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Property Right Status – ZE30 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP65 ascribes property right holder (is property right holder ascribed by) Actor – E39 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Property Right Status – ZE30 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP64 has property right subject (is property right subject of) Legal Object – E72 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Obligation Status – ZE28 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP59 ascribes obligation relation (is obligation relation ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Obligation Status – ZE28 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP60 ascribes debtee (is debtee ascribed by) Actor – E39 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Obligation Status – ZE28 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP57 has obligation subject (is obligation subject of) Dimension – E54 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Dating Status – ZE25 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP56 ascribes dating relation (is dating relation ascibed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Dating Status – ZE25 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP54 ascribes relative date (is relative date ascribed by) Period – E4 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Dating Status – ZE25 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP55 has dating subject (is dating subject of) Period – E4 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Transfer of Property Right – ZE29 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP63 transferred property right over (had change in property right through) Legal Object – E72 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Transfer of Property Right – ZE29 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP62 transferred property right from (surrendered property right through) Actor – E39 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Transfer of Property Right – ZE29 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP61 transferred property right to (acquired property right through) Actor – E39 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Utterance Event – ZE16 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP50 uttered (was uttered in) Information Object – E73 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Denied (see comment)
Set Status – ZE15 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP49 ascribes set belonging relation (is set belonging relation ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Set Status – ZE15 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP48 ascribes set (is set ascribed by) Notional Set – ZE24 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-10-31 Validated
Notional Set – ZE24 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP51 has former or current set member (is current or former set member of) CRM Entity – E1 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Set Status – ZE15 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP47 has set belonging subject (is set belonging subject of) CRM Entity – E1 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Similarity Status – ZE14 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP46 ascribes similarity mode (is similarity mode ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Similarity Status – ZE14 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP45 ascribes similarity relation (is similarity relation ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Similarity Status – ZE14 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP44 ascribes similarity target (is similarity target ascribed by) CRM Entity – E1 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Similarity Status – ZE14 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP43 has similarity subject (is similarity subject of) CRM Entity – E1 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Custodial Status – ZE7 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP22 ascribes custodial relation (is custodial relation ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
test class – ZE99 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing (0,n) zp99 test property (inverse of test property) (1,n) Document – E31 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 Denied (see comment)
Speech Act – ZE13 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP42 intentionally initiated (was intentionally initiated by) Institutional Fact – ZE1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-10-31 Validated
Speech Act – ZE13 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP41 uttered (was uttered by) Information Object – E73 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Speech Act – ZE13 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP40 performed (was performed by) Design or Procedure – E29 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Speech Act – ZE13 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP39 invoked (was invoked by) Design or Procedure – E29 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Denied (see comment)
Referential Status – ZE12 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP38 ascribes referential mode (is referential mode ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Referential Status – ZE12 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP37 ascribes referential relation (is referential relation ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Referential Status – ZE12 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP36 ascribes referent (is referent ascribed by) CRM Entity – E1 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Referential Status – ZE12 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP35 has referential subject (is referential subject of) Propositional Object – E89 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Membership Status – ZE11 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP34 ascribes membership relation (is membership relation ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Membership Status – ZE11 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP33 ascribes group (is group ascribed by) Group – E74 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Membership Status – ZE11 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP32 has membership subject (is membership subject of) Actor – E39 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Family Status – ZE10 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP31 ascribes familial relation (is familial relation ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Family Status – ZE10 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP30 ascribes relative (is relative ascribed by) Person – E21 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Family Status – ZE10 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP29 has familial subject (is familial subject of) Person – E21 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Residential Status – ZE9 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP28 ascribes residence relation (is residence relation ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Residential Status – ZE9 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP27 acribes residence place (is residence place ascribed by) Place – E53 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Residential Status – ZE9 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP26 has residence subject (is residence subject of) Actor – E39 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Ownership Status – ZE8 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP25 ascribes ownership relation (is ownership relation ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Ownership Status – ZE8 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP24 ascribes owner (is owners ascribed by) Actor – E39 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-11-02 Validated
Custodial Status – ZE7 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP21 ascribes custodian (is custodian ascribed by) Actor – E39 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Social Status – ZE6 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP19 ascribes social status relation (is social status relation ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Social Status – ZE6 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP18 ascribes social status (is social status ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Social Status – ZE6 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP17 has social status subject (is social status subject of) Actor – E39 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Function Status – ZE5 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP16 ascribes functional relation (is functional relation ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Function Status – ZE5 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP15 ascribes function (is function ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Classificatory Status – ZE4 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP13 ascribes classification relation (is classification relations ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-11-02 Validated
Classificatory Status – ZE4 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP12 ascribes classification (is classification ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Classificatory Status – ZE4 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP11 has classificatory subject (is classificatory subject of) CRM Entity – E1 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Contact Point Status – ZE3 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP10 ascribes contact point relation (is contact point relation ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Contact Point Status – ZE3 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP8 has contact point subject (is contact point subject of) Actor – E39 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Appellative Status – ZE2 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP7 ascribes appellative relation (is appellative relation ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Appellative Status – ZE2 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP6 ascribes appellation (is appellation ascribed by) Appellation – E41 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Appellative Status – ZE2 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP5 has appellative subject (is appellative subject of) CRM Entity – E1 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Institutional Fact – ZE1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP4 holds for (holds) Group – E74 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Institutional Fact – ZE1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP3 ascribes intentional relation (is intentional relation ascribed by) Type – E55 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Institutional Fact – ZE1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP2 ascribes intentional target (is intentional target ascribed by) CRM Entity – E1 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated
Institutional Fact – ZE1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing ZP1 has intentional subject (is intentional subject of) CRM Entity – E1 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 Validated

Relations

Filter by

Source Source namespace Relation Target Target namespace Last updated Type
Institutional Fact – ZE1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Temporal Entity – E2 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Appellative Status – ZE2 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Institutional Fact – ZE1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Contact Point Status – ZE3 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Appellative Status – ZE2 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-23 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Function Status – ZE5 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Classificatory Status – ZE4 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Classificatory Status – ZE4 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Institutional Fact – ZE1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Social Status – ZE6 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Classificatory Status – ZE4 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Residential Status – ZE9 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Institutional Fact – ZE1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Family Status – ZE10 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Institutional Fact – ZE1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Membership Status – ZE11 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Institutional Fact – ZE1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Referential Status – ZE12 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Institutional Fact – ZE1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-23 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Speech Act – ZE13 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Activity – E7 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Similarity Status – ZE14 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Institutional Fact – ZE1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Set Status – ZE15 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Institutional Fact – ZE1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Notional Set – ZE24 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Conceptual Object – E28 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Utterance Event – ZE16 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Activity – E7 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Digital Reading – ZE17 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Speech Act – ZE13 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-11-10 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Critical Reading – ZE18 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Speech Act – ZE13 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-23 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Naming – ZE19 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Attribute Assignment – E13 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Digital Reading – ZE17 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Digital Machine Event – D7 CRMdig version 4.0 2023-11-10 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Transfer of Property Right – ZE29 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Speech Act – ZE13 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-10-13 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Declarative Acquisition – ZE20 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Acquisition – E8 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Declarative Acquisition – ZE20 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Transfer of Property Right – ZE29 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-23 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Declarative Transfer of Custody – ZE21 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Transfer of Custody – E10 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Declarative Transfer of Custody – ZE21 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Transfer of Property Right – ZE29 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-04-04 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Declarative Joining – ZE22 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Speech Act – ZE13 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-23 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Declarative Joining – ZE22 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Joining – E85 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Declarative Leaving – ZE23 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Leaving – E86 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Declarative Leaving – ZE23 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Speech Act – ZE13 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-11-10 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Dating Status – ZE25 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Institutional Fact – ZE1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-23 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Dating Declaration – ZE26 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Speech Act – ZE13 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-23 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Declaration of Obligation – ZE27 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Speech Act – ZE13 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Obligation Status – ZE28 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Institutional Fact – ZE1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-23 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Property Right Status – ZE30 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Institutional Fact – ZE1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-23 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Custodial Status – ZE7 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Property Right Status – ZE30 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Ownership Status – ZE8 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Property Right Status – ZE30 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Group Role Assignment – ZE31 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Type Assignment – E17 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Institutional Status – ZE32 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Social Status – ZE6 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-01-10 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Dating Declaration – ZE26 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Purchase – E96 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-31 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Declarative Formation – ZE33 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Speech Act – ZE13 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-24 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Declarative Formation – ZE33 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Formation – E66 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Declarative Dissolution – ZE34 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Speech Act – ZE13 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-06-01 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
Declarative Dissolution – ZE34 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subClassOf Dissolution – E68 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 ClassesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
has appellative subject (is appellative subject of) – ZP5 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf has intentional subject (is intentional subject of) – ZP1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes appellative relation (is appellative relation ascribed by) – ZP7 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional relation (is intentional relation ascribed by) – ZP3 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes appellation (is appellation ascribed by) – ZP6 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional target (is intentional target ascribed by) – ZP2 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
has contact point subject (is contact point subject of) – ZP8 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf has appellative subject (is appellative subject of) – ZP5 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-23 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes contact point (is contact point ascribed by) – ZP9 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes appellation (is appellation ascribed by) – ZP6 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-23 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes contact point relation (is contact point relation ascribed by) – ZP10 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes appellative relation (is appellative relation ascribed by) – ZP7 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-23 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
has classificatory subject (is classificatory subject of) – ZP11 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf has intentional subject (is intentional subject of) – ZP1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes classification (is classification ascribed by) – ZP12 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional target (is intentional target ascribed by) – ZP2 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes classification relation (is classification relations ascribed by) – ZP13 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional relation (is intentional relation ascribed by) – ZP3 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
has functional subject (is functional subject of) – ZP14 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf has classificatory subject (is classificatory subject of) – ZP11 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes function (is function ascribed by) – ZP15 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes classification (is classification ascribed by) – ZP12 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes functional relation (is functional relation ascribed by) – ZP16 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes classification relation (is classification relations ascribed by) – ZP13 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
has social status subject (is social status subject of) – ZP17 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf has classificatory subject (is classificatory subject of) – ZP11 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes social status (is social status ascribed by) – ZP18 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes classification (is classification ascribed by) – ZP12 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes social status relation (is social status relation ascribed by) – ZP19 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes classification relation (is classification relations ascribed by) – ZP13 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
has custodial subject (is custodial subject of) – ZP20 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf has intentional subject (is intentional subject of) – ZP1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes custodian (is custodian ascribed by) – ZP21 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional target (is intentional target ascribed by) – ZP2 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes custodial relation (is custodial relation ascribed by) – ZP22 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional relation (is intentional relation ascribed by) – ZP3 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
has ownership subject (is ownership subject of) – ZP23 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf has intentional subject (is intentional subject of) – ZP1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes owner (is owners ascribed by) – ZP24 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional target (is intentional target ascribed by) – ZP2 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes ownership relation (is ownership relation ascribed by) – ZP25 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional relation (is intentional relation ascribed by) – ZP3 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
acribes residence place (is residence place ascribed by) – ZP27 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional target (is intentional target ascribed by) – ZP2 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-10-16 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
has residence subject (is residence subject of) – ZP26 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf has intentional subject (is intentional subject of) – ZP1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-11-02 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes residence relation (is residence relation ascribed by) – ZP28 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional relation (is intentional relation ascribed by) – ZP3 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-06-01 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
has familial subject (is familial subject of) – ZP29 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf has intentional subject (is intentional subject of) – ZP1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes relative (is relative ascribed by) – ZP30 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional target (is intentional target ascribed by) – ZP2 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes familial relation (is familial relation ascribed by) – ZP31 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional relation (is intentional relation ascribed by) – ZP3 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
has membership subject (is membership subject of) – ZP32 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf has intentional subject (is intentional subject of) – ZP1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes group (is group ascribed by) – ZP33 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional target (is intentional target ascribed by) – ZP2 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes membership relation (is membership relation ascribed by) – ZP34 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional relation (is intentional relation ascribed by) – ZP3 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes referent (is referent ascribed by) – ZP36 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional target (is intentional target ascribed by) – ZP2 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-10-16 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes referential relation (is referential relation ascribed by) – ZP37 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional relation (is intentional relation ascribed by) – ZP3 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-23 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
invoked (was invoked by) – ZP39 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf used specific technique (was used by) – P33 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
performed (was performed by) – ZP40 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf used specific technique (was used by) – P33 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
uttered (was uttered by) – ZP41 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf used specific object (was used for) – P16 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
has referential subject (is referential subject of) – ZP35 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf has intentional subject (is intentional subject of) – ZP1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-10-16 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
test property (inverse of test property) – zp99 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf lists (is listed in) – P71 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
has similarity subject (is similarity subject of) – ZP43 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf has intentional subject (is intentional subject of) – ZP1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes similarity target (is similarity target ascribed by) – ZP44 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional target (is intentional target ascribed by) – ZP2 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-10-16 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes similarity relation (is similarity relation ascribed by) – ZP45 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional relation (is intentional relation ascribed by) – ZP3 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-10-16 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
has set belonging subject (is set belonging subject of) – ZP47 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf has intentional subject (is intentional subject of) – ZP1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-10-16 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes set (is set ascribed by) – ZP48 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional target (is intentional target ascribed by) – ZP2 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-10-16 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes set belonging relation (is set belonging relation ascribed by) – ZP49 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional relation (is intentional relation ascribed by) – ZP3 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
uttered (was uttered in) – ZP50 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf used specific object (was used for) – P16 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
transferred property right to (acquired property right through) – ZP61 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf carried out by (performed) – P14 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
transferred property right from (surrendered property right through) – ZP62 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf carried out by (performed) – P14 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
transferred property right over (had change in property right through) – ZP63 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf used specific object (was used for) – P16 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes relative date (is relative date ascribed by) – ZP54 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional target (is intentional target ascribed by) – ZP2 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-23 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
has dating subject (is dating subject of) – ZP55 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf has intentional subject (is intentional subject of) – ZP1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-23 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes dating relation (is dating relation ascibed by) – ZP56 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional relation (is intentional relation ascribed by) – ZP3 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-11-28 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
has obligation subject (is obligation subject of) – ZP57 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf has intentional subject (is intentional subject of) – ZP1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-23 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes debtor (is debtor ascribed by) – ZP58 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional target (is intentional target ascribed by) – ZP2 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-23 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes debtee (is debtee ascribed by) – ZP60 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional target (is intentional target ascribed by) – ZP2 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-23 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes obligation relation (is obligation relation ascribed by) – ZP59 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional relation (is intentional relation ascribed by) – ZP3 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-23 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
has property right subject (is property right subject of) – ZP64 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf has intentional subject (is intentional subject of) – ZP1 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-23 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes property right holder (is property right holder ascribed by) – ZP65 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional target (is intentional target ascribed by) – ZP2 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-23 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes property right relation (is property right relation ascribed by) – ZP66 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes intentional relation (is intentional relation ascribed by) – ZP3 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-23 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
has institutional status subject (is institutional status subject of) – ZP71 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf has social status subject (is social status subject of) – ZP17 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-10-16 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes institutional status (is institutional status ascribed by) – ZP72 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes social status (is social status ascribed by) – ZP18 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-24 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
ascribes institutional status relation (is institutional status relation ascribed by) – ZP73 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf ascribes social status relation (is social status relation ascribed by) – ZP19 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-24 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
has social status subject (is social status subject of) – ZP17 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf has classificatory subject (is classificatory subject of) – ZP11 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing 2023-05-22 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
generated obligation upon (had obligation generated upon by) – ZP67 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf carried out by (performed) – P14 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation
generated obligation to (had obligation to generated by) – ZP68 CRM for Art and Architectural Argumentation Version 1.5.1 ongoing rdfs:subPropertyOf carried out by (performed) – P14 CIDOC CRM version 7.1.2 2023-10-16 PropertiesRelation-HierarchyAssociation

Notes

Show Note Type Language Entity

Comments

List of mismatches with reference namespaces

Entities listed here are not correctly associated with your reference namespaces. They are displayed in red in your ongoing namespace. They may not be available in the version of the selected space. Or you may not have selected any version of a reference namespace.
Please make the necessary corrections before proceeding.

Type of relation Entity Namespace Error type